You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Moderating Freesound sounds can be stressful. Volunteering eventually leads to encountering distress-causing sounds (contributes to burnout). When you defer problem sounds, you still see them in the assignment queue, which reminds you of the problems and can make you feel guilty (contributes to burnout) for letting other moderators deal with the hard cases. Also you have to use your own brain to remember negative information (contributes to burnout) about which users/avatars tend to problem sounds when a computer could easily do it for you. The consequent inability to use "Assign all" slows down moderation.
One of the reasons I had a huge hiatus from Freesound moderation is the inability to escape content that was stressful to moderate.
Distress can mean:
content that is viscerally unpleasant to the moderator due to content (disgusting content, music grey area), creation method (ai, legal grey area) or quality (constant low quality audio/metadata)
content of users moderation of which requires communication but the communication of this particular moderator and user pair is highly stressful (uploader unwillingness to improve metadata, uploader ignoring deferred improvement requests)
Solution:
Implement a filter based on user in moderation assignment. Store "ignored" users
Benefit:
Moderators who are compatible with "out of sight, out of mind" thinking can experience relief (I confirm this works very well for me) and burnout can be delayed/prevented
Drawbacks:
Potentially other moderators (incompatible with "out of sight, out of mind") will be bothered by any pending sounds, even if filtered out and feel guilty/responsible for these sounds still pending. These hypothetical moderators can then experience even more stress which perhaps was more evenly distributed before.
Admins might end up having to deal with more stressful content contributing to their burnout, taking away from their time available for Freesound.
Some sounds might end up never moderated, which seems like an acceptable solution. Handling a large quantity of such sounds is something to consider down the line if implemented.
The suggestion to filter per-user is based on years of Freesound volunteer moderation experience and I stand by it. However, potentially one user might change upload content/behavior which might then get missed. This can be counteracted by making it easy to check on ignored pending sounds (quick client side filtering instead of server-side as seen in userscript below).
Implementation example:
Firefox/Chrome userscript for Greasemonkey/Tampermonkey: https://github.com/qubodup/freesound-mod_user_filter/ cc0 code. Use video, install guide, feature list present in Readme. Warning: uses jQuery.
Screenshot:
[anonymized names/avatars]
Notes
In my testing, I stopped using "favorite" after a few days. It is minimally useful to identify highly active users over a course of multiple days. This adds a little bit of psychological motivation boost ("ah, I see some green, this is very likely to be at least partially a pleasant experience" as opposed to not knowing what to expect unless inspecting users' pending sounds individually) but this is rare.
The "assign all" button must be protected by a JS confirm() box, as it assigns invisible users too.
Implementation of an assign_users() method / url / api call might be required, which accepts a list of user IDs although my ugly iframe solutions works quite well for now.
pressing "ignore" should not hide the user instantly, as double-clicks happen. The user should be marked as hidden. A js refresh button could be added. Behavior for assigning currently visible users could have a warning or require a refresh view action first or be replaced with a 'refresh list' button if not yet reflected changes are in the list.
The issue is solved for me personally through the userscript. This adds imbalance: moderators who are unaware or do not want or cannot use extensions/userscripts are at a potential disadvantage.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Moderating Freesound sounds can be stressful. Volunteering eventually leads to encountering distress-causing sounds (contributes to burnout). When you defer problem sounds, you still see them in the assignment queue, which reminds you of the problems and can make you feel guilty (contributes to burnout) for letting other moderators deal with the hard cases. Also you have to use your own brain to remember negative information (contributes to burnout) about which users/avatars tend to problem sounds when a computer could easily do it for you. The consequent inability to use "Assign all" slows down moderation.
One of the reasons I had a huge hiatus from Freesound moderation is the inability to escape content that was stressful to moderate.
Distress can mean:
Solution:
Benefit:
Drawbacks:
Implementation example:
Firefox/Chrome userscript for Greasemonkey/Tampermonkey: https://github.com/qubodup/freesound-mod_user_filter/ cc0 code. Use video, install guide, feature list present in Readme. Warning: uses jQuery.
Screenshot:
Notes
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: