You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Currently, if a model is shown in an environment that supports Latex (such as Pluto and documentation), we have chosen to show only the equations of the system typeset as latex math. This only looks good for toy models, toy in the sense of small and uses exclusively mathematical notation/variable names. For more realistic models, this instead often looks rather terrible, and also fails to show other relevant information, such as variables and parameters etc.
As an example, here's how we display a PI controller
The terminal output is both looking nicer and at the same time more informative, I'd prefer if this was the default in all environments, and latex display can be opt in for those who are interested and have a suitable model where it makes sense.
Here's the terminal output for the same system for reference
julia> ModelingToolkitStandardLibrary.Blocks.LimPID(; name=:hrfd)
Model hrfd with 10 (18) equations
States (20):reference₊u(t) [defaults to 0.0]: Inner variable in RealInput reference
measurement₊u(t) [defaults to 0.0]: Inner variable in RealInput measurement
ctr_output₊u(t) [defaults to 0.0]: Inner variable in RealOutput ctr_output
addP₊input1₊u(t) [defaults to 0.0]: Inner variable in RealInput input1
addP₊input2₊u(t) [defaults to 0.0]: Inner variable in RealInput input2
addP₊output₊u(t) [defaults to 0.0]: Inner variable in RealOutput output
gainPID₊u(t) [defaults to gainPID₊u_start]: Input of SISO system
gainPID₊y(t) [defaults to gainPID₊y_start]: Output of SISO system
gainPID₊input₊u(t) [defaults to gainPID₊u_start]: Inner variable in RealInput input
gainPID₊output₊u(t) [defaults to gainPID₊y_start]: Inner variable in RealOutput output
⋮
Parameters (14):
addP₊k1 [defaults to 1]: Gain of Add input1
addP₊k2 [defaults to -1]: Gain of Add input2
gainPID₊u_start [defaults to 0.0]
gainPID₊y_start [defaults to 0.0]
gainPID₊k [defaults to 1]: Gain
addPID₊k1 [defaults to 1]: Gain of Add input1
addPID₊k2 [defaults to 1]: Gain of Add input2
addPID₊k3 [defaults to 1]: Gain of Add input3
limiter₊u_start [defaults to NaN]
limiter₊y_start [defaults to NaN]
⋮
The latex output also has a very large number of corner cases where it just looks very poor and sometimes borderline incorrect, like here, so having it as default doesn't feel right
It may be a Pluto restriction as we have to output something for the show on the special MIME type. I don't know if we can show multiple things, part of it being TeX.
Currently, if a model is shown in an environment that supports Latex (such as Pluto and documentation), we have chosen to show only the equations of the system typeset as latex math. This only looks good for toy models, toy in the sense of small and uses exclusively mathematical notation/variable names. For more realistic models, this instead often looks rather terrible, and also fails to show other relevant information, such as variables and parameters etc.
As an example, here's how we display a PI controller
The terminal output is both looking nicer and at the same time more informative, I'd prefer if this was the default in all environments, and latex display can be opt in for those who are interested and have a suitable model where it makes sense.
Here's the terminal output for the same system for reference
The latex output also has a very large number of corner cases where it just looks very poor and sometimes borderline incorrect, like here, so having it as default doesn't feel right
A related issue is
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: