JFrog Artifactory git-lfs upload failure

[dbiner]

Hi,

by testing git-lfs-migrate.jar on your repository by using Artifactory as lfs-server the process runs through but no data is uploaded to Artifactory.
I used the following script

#!/bin/bash
java -jar java/git-lfs-migrate.jar \
     -s git-lfs-migrate.git \
     -d git-lfs-migrate-converted.git \
     -l http://<user>:<pwd>@<server>/artifactory/api/lfs/<lfs-repo> \
     "*.md" "*.jar"

and the output was

[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main - LFS server: OK
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main - Reading full objects list...
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   found: 1
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   found: 601
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main - Found objects: 601
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main - Converting object without dependencies in 2 threads...
[pool-2-thread-2] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   processed: 1/140, uploaded: 0/0
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   processed: 140/140, uploaded: 17/17
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main - Converting graph in single thread...
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   completed: 1/461
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   completed: 461/461
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main - Recreating refs...
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 2145c973f03617cd07361717785fd58604c94419 -> c176ab2c82ee7a780d2c193a70e8fa79ac2e9f89 (HEAD)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 31edfcd65064468d35e66f4018c3c91af728601d -> 43430174791681f653fb7fe0651e929ae0a0eecd (refs/heads/globs)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 2145c973f03617cd07361717785fd58604c94419 -> c176ab2c82ee7a780d2c193a70e8fa79ac2e9f89 (refs/heads/master)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 5e19ff822c082878c5217af5dd95e15abe15ae76 -> 556239f2cf1f3357f239b1055fc4e3ebb8ec67fd (refs/pull/15/head)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 7186b36f2d69c756e9ae8fdde9eb07d2ad53d8f7 -> ba0e59f7f2e28e647c14fa9fecb7f85a410844cd (refs/pull/16/head)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 5c7486fb65b0ada289b481ce7262d7945b1d5994 -> 4b461df37747873ca75036e992d4622c0beea83d (refs/pull/19/head)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 3125deb04614b6b5a2d4607794d92b282a2c32f3 -> 176a60a55d62f0be03343da5ae789f4e2e26491f (refs/pull/22/head)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: bd2a5582dfa38143efadb9e75dbb6b658adb53fd -> 0c38a82f20a7b28398130998eee32327098258aa (refs/pull/22/merge)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 7b44b48351d3422a6a30b6c4d6086387a200b794 -> eeb20695c4fececf9be7984823c2d39be8d23b31 (refs/pull/6/head)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: ea0e304cc0ccdef4f21213a4167fb2337f65a069 -> 8991fd979168f213a094c3e6c20fcbd4f8e865cc (refs/pull/7/head)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 6c3cd1def3c4877022e29d0a0de4a6ec0485874e -> 2d6bcf34b69ef2bc5e3c86445809854387565c09 (refs/pull/9/head)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 005e6e010617e37be2bf25eeeddf50bac8f09a6a -> a6b9aafcf637a51496d174531f2a1cb06288de6c (refs/tags/0.0.1)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 2a64aa0c7796b5fa324ab7ccfb049685b52bdf67 -> a06ba123abccada0e5c691b6ef2c4e16cd73f1d7 (refs/tags/0.0.10)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 52fcfa20c8b14b99f001812cd93e5ea1eb476408 -> 676d0bea5c721ad57d115251a5f8e48cc5c9193e (refs/tags/0.0.11)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 7b6a43f12116f81dafb85cc03b1a622cfbb36362 -> ff54ae8f856128747c0a9b53725f2cef5349b19a (refs/tags/0.0.12)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: fce590df6f4f86b03f42de4a69a7d1a40fd06fc0 -> e63e71506bbf737f43810a9311184446e4a2b09e (refs/tags/0.0.13)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: d2fd13d26c2cfd2e81936221bc4d04e982172a34 -> b18354ec9137522b11305f13e34c146168fcc13e (refs/tags/0.0.14)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 61243791234be1cb92ad45ed3961ccea8ca6bbc0 -> 095fefc0bef3da728a289bc606507db21d515415 (refs/tags/0.0.15)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: ebc13e8293ff20b77a19e2d212e48435b6a1035a -> f733468cf7c1d1881dd1ede33a90f83b0862b668 (refs/tags/0.0.2)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: bdddc4246b3e31b3a645e1973ff59679c407a5f1 -> 657fe828f8c5385ada6a0a80919f3757689912ef (refs/tags/0.0.3)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: dbac21c2c1a0c6d600ee5bde6e60c7f510d3f82b -> 6a1a1a6b21f4b2207a21d5b2732e8ace1f2ee78b (refs/tags/0.0.4)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 36f2fab6edddbd9703b41ca7b0c2251fd575da0b -> 8d847b4878447a42901012e893e8a4903cd034af (refs/tags/0.0.5)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 04701dba2a82f59df9415ebdae96f772253e725b -> 048695c95064bc8f72034c95dc9fefbb8ab5c192 (refs/tags/0.0.6)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 724e0d35deac4209755e00103c10b42408b049b4 -> 4dd2059afd59e9f26a8f2b0731c050c4988ebe4f (refs/tags/0.0.7)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: d2e19aa87cace25936becf4cbac15cc16ce4df79 -> 984383f01c3d3aeeee49e0bf4b0008bc68afa173 (refs/tags/0.0.8)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: ba899229359132c6d8f51a7d207e392a2f883211 -> d934b46ca5928b38757bbece7370e0d0c75f95f9 (refs/tags/0.0.9)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 7e7cccccb1022c77ad5cb07fe3fd996d26a30fd5 -> 46c4f55918d35a1dea2dcb5c1a1814a12431ef3a (refs/tags/0.1.0)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 61243791234be1cb92ad45ed3961ccea8ca6bbc0 -> 095fefc0bef3da728a289bc606507db21d515415 (refs/tags/0.1.1)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 6c3cd1def3c4877022e29d0a0de4a6ec0485874e -> 2d6bcf34b69ef2bc5e3c86445809854387565c09 (refs/tags/0.2.0)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 357092b16879390d69ba0c1a1e4481a10831f2de -> e103cfe2a0da872a92b4a4acc7cad314ebf75ed4 (refs/tags/0.2.1)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 10b441e662f1cf02f3899db1da281457c5af44cc -> 7925efb628965e4a0e5fe6b1229769fd5402a6e3 (refs/tags/0.2.2)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: cd0c7829dafa0dabffb0c4eb32ca6f790e142338 -> c0dbac11c8524a9975aa40f2634c9179c7367061 (refs/tags/0.2.3)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main -   convert ref: 2145c973f03617cd07361717785fd58604c94419 -> c176ab2c82ee7a780d2c193a70e8fa79ac2e9f89 (refs/tags/0.2.4)
[main] INFO git.lfs.migrate.Main - Convert time: 1431

I tried to use the GitHub lfs-test-server which worked without problems (all lfs objects where uploaded). For both lfs-servers, the outputs of git-lfs-migrate.jar are the same.
Sadly I did not find a way to increase the verbosity to get more information.

[SeaOfCowards]

Hi,
got the very same problem.
The output looks similar, saying that everything was uploaded but no files are actually listed in artifactory.

[bozaro]

I downloaded Artifactory trial. I will try to fix this issue in the near future.

[bozaro]

Looks like JFrog Artifactory has incorrect Git LFS server implementation: git-as-svn/git-lfs-java#4

I send a report to JFrog via "Report a Bug" service (https://www.jfrog.com/support-service/support/).

Also I will implement limited workaround for issue in this weekend.

[bozaro]

Now git-lfs-migrate does not consider all of the files have already uploaded into Artifactory.
But unfortunatelly it require DELETE permission for reupload already uploaded files.