Spaces don't really work with a fresh install

[matrixbot]

This issue was originally created by @adorakalb at matrix-org/dendrite#3165.

Background information

• Dendrite version or git SHA: matrixdotorg/dendrite-monolith:v0.13.1
• SQLite3 or Postgres?: postgres 15
• Running in Docker?: yes
• go version: -
• Client used (if applicable): Element 1.11.37 & FluffyChat 1.12.0

Description

• What is the problem: Spaces that are not on my Instance don't work or don't work enough to be of any use.
• Who is affected: probably all users on my Instance lila.network
• How is this bug manifesting:
  Element: When trying to join public spaces, the list of rooms can't be fetched. I therefore also can't join any rooms.
  FluffyChat: When trying to add spaces, the app tells me "Unrecognized request".
  Debug logs don't show any weird errors (at least for me, i just started with matrix)
• When did this first appear: Since setting up the instance with v0.13.1 yesterday

Steps to reproduce

• open Element or FluffyChat
• try to join spaces (i tested it with #codeberg-space:matrix.org and #nerdberg:nerdberg.de
• for Element: See the join screen, click join, see that the room list is not displaying with an error:

I don't really see any relevant logs with debug logging turned on. The only odd log line is the following:

dendrite-dendrite-1  | time="2023-08-02T06:09:23.430054766Z" level=debug msg="Responding to sync since client gave up or timeout was reached" device_id=n-oLIY9e limit=20 req.id=QN51cSIiiVUW req.method=GET req.path=/_matrix/client/r0/sync since=s211_0_30_0_0_171_174_56_0 timeout=30s user_id="@lauralani:lila.network"

I dont know if that's in any way relevant.

Federation seems to work as expected, i can chat without any problems with people on other instances. The federation checker also says all is good.

Thanks in advance.

[matrixbot]

This comment was originally posted by @kir68k at matrix-org/dendrite#3165 (comment).

Same here using 0.13.1, although a private space hosted on my instance doesn't work either. My dendrite binary is compiled from source, but I don't think that should matter.
I can't find anything in my logs as well.

Edit 2

Disregarding the previous edit, clicking "Explore rooms" shows the following, more clear message:

[matrixbot]

This comment was originally posted by @swedgwood at matrix-org/dendrite#3165 (comment).

Hey @lauralani & @kir68k, for some space features to work you need to enable an MSC flag in your dendrite config (see the v0.13.1 FAQ). I have recently merged a PR which enables them by default and should be available in the next release.

Let me know if you still have issues with MSC2946 enabled (or if you already had it enabled when you got these errors)

EDIT: just realised @lauralani said spaces that are not on their instance, implying ones on their instance are working (and that you have the MSC enabled), so ignore me if thats the case - Though @kir68k since you said no spaces work, still work a check if the MSC is enabled.

[matrixbot]

This comment was originally posted by @kir68k at matrix-org/dendrite#3165 (comment).

Though @kir68k since you said no spaces work, still work a check if the MSC is enabled.

I had the MSC disabled, enabling it made spaces on my instance work properly, as well as spaces on remote instances. Thanks.

[matrixbot]

This comment was originally posted by @adorakalb at matrix-org/dendrite#3165 (comment).

@swedgwood that seems to have fixed it!
I can use spaces now with fluffychat, I have to check some more tho :) thanks!

[matrixbot]

This comment was originally posted by @swedgwood at matrix-org/dendrite#3165 (comment).

Glad to know this resolved it for both of you! I'll close this issue now but feel free to reopen it if the issue persists :)