From 12053853d4bc625b7a286d5c6df1027c8537fe0f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kusumachalasani Date: Mon, 18 Jul 2022 13:16:58 +0530 Subject: [PATCH] experiment with multiple tunables Signed-off-by: kusumachalasani --- spring-petclinic/experiment-1/README.md | 34 ++++++ spring-petclinic/experiment-1/baseline.csv | 2 + spring-petclinic/experiment-1/benchmark.yaml | 47 ++++++++ .../experiment-1/experiment-data.csv | 102 ++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 185 insertions(+) create mode 100644 spring-petclinic/experiment-1/README.md create mode 100644 spring-petclinic/experiment-1/baseline.csv create mode 100644 spring-petclinic/experiment-1/benchmark.yaml create mode 100644 spring-petclinic/experiment-1/experiment-data.csv diff --git a/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/README.md b/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/README.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..45e9f158 --- /dev/null +++ b/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +## All the experiments in this folder were run on dedicated infrastructure. + +# Goal of the experiment: +- Maximize Throughput. + +- For details on slo and benchmark, look into [benchmark.yaml](benchmark.yaml) + +# Summary of data + +### Configuration Details: +``` +- JVM openj9-0.21.0 +``` +- Machine: +``` + - Server: openshift cluster v4.8.13 + Master nodes 3 + Worker nodes 3 + CPU per node 32 + Memory per node 64G + + - Client: RHEL 8.3 + CPU 64 + Memory 64G +``` +- Load: +``` + Users : 512 + Threads : 56 +``` + + +Note: Best configuration from multiple trials is picked based on high throughput, no errors while running the load and ensuring the data has met the convergence criteria. +Each trial would have an individual configuartion based on the tunables.For information on the configuration of a particular trial, look into experiment-data.csv diff --git a/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/baseline.csv b/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/baseline.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..56315efb --- /dev/null +++ b/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/baseline.csv @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +Instances , Throughput , Responsetime , MEM_MEAN , CPU_MEAN , CPU_MIN , CPU_MAX , MEM_MIN , MEM_MAX , CPU_REQ , MEM_REQ , CPU_LIM , MEM_LIM , WEB_ERRORS +1,155.911,1203.33,582.103,2.2138,1.85037636722593,2.6114387174581,531,629,4, 4096M ,4, 4096M ,0 diff --git a/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/benchmark.yaml b/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/benchmark.yaml new file mode 100644 index 00000000..92247e3c --- /dev/null +++ b/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/benchmark.yaml @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +application_name: spring-petclinic +slo: + - slo_class: throughput + objective_function: throughput + direction: maximize + function_variables: + - name: throughput + value_type: double +layers: + - layer_level: 1 + tunables: + - name: virtualized + value_type: categorical + choices: ["true", "false"] + - name: aggressive + value_type: categorical + choices: ["true", "false"] + - name: shareclasses + value_type: categorical + choices: ["true", "false"] + - name: gc + value_type: categorical + choices: ["gencon", "balanced", "optavgpause", "optthruput", "metronome"] + layer_name: openj9 + layer_details: openj9 tunables + +git_url: 'https://github.com/kusumachalasani/hpo.git' +git_branch: 'main' +benchmark: spring-petclinic +image: 'kruize/spring_petclinic:2.2.0-jdk-11.0.8-openj9-0.21.0' +iterations: 3 +warmupIterations: 3 +warmupTime: 60 s +measurementIterations: 3 +measurementTime: 60 s +connections: 256 +instances: 1 +server_config: + - name: scalelabperf + - master_nodes: 3 + - worker_nodes: 3 + - cpu_per_node: 32 + - mem_per_node: 64G +client_config: + - name: scalelabperf-client + - cpu: 64 + - mem: 64G diff --git a/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/experiment-data.csv b/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/experiment-data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..6ba2bd4d --- /dev/null +++ b/spring-petclinic/experiment-1/experiment-data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +Trial,memoryRequest,cpuRequest,gc,virtualized,shareclasses,aggressive,Instances,Throughput,Responsetime,MEM_MEAN,CPU_MEAN,CPU_MIN,CPU_MAX,MEM_MIN,MEM_MAX,CPU_REQ,MEM_REQ,CPU_LIM,MEM_LIM,WEB_ERRORS +76,3701,3.8,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,194.367,902.667,634.421,2.08557,1.72490250554444,2.43405812766484,585,702,3.8,3701.0M,3.8,3701.0M,0 +84,3831,4,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,179.267,995.444,650.846,2.22614,1.88316933836667,2.54922804185556,549,695,4,3831.0M,4,3831.0M,0 +64,3570,3.9,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,174.6,1039,617.195,2.14052,1.7406098247963,2.48463527579338,559,669,3.9,3570.0M,3.9,3570.0M,0 +79,4094,3.9,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,173.7,1049.67,630.143,2.13733,1.74267876314074,2.4687095895477,567,707,3.9,4094.0M,3.9,4094.0M,0 +61,3765,3.9,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,172.522,1049.89,639.166,2.13453,1.81085029071852,2.47550457859114,593,701,3.9,3765.0M,3.9,3765.0M,0 +66,3127,3.9,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,171.044,1081.22,643.904,2.17347,1.89536565988889,2.50099591262334,547,712,3.9,3127.0M,3.9,3127.0M,0 +55,4089,4,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,169.711,1081.22,619.244,2.21953,1.86441621038519,2.52875676983333,559,677,4,4089.0M,4,4089.0M,0 +65,3549,3.8,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,169.411,1056.56,617.727,2.11809,1.7829956205963,2.43103008720964,543,686,3.8,3549.0M,3.8,3549.0M,0 +95,4092,4,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,164.467,1139.22,613.982,2.22,1.89312516224815,2.58641069750008,546,687,4,4092.0M,4,4092.0M,0 +34,3437,3.6,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,162.833,1138.33,629.763,2.00699,1.70189535948519,2.38711876292214,566,709,3.6,3437.0M,3.6,3437.0M,0 +71,3435,3.8,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,162.489,1126.44,605.656,2.10328,1.75468346725556,2.47267506196698,508,687,3.8,3435.0M,3.8,3435.0M,0 +12,4034,4,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,162.311,1160.56,601.238,2.20998,1.93787349368148,2.56175252544618,532,706,4,4034.0M,4,4034.0M,0 +86,3811,4,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,162.267,1123.89,650.865,2.19978,1.85759830881852,2.53271597468518,580,714,4,3811.0M,4,3811.0M,0 +97,3962,4,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,160.744,1169.89,601.517,2.21739,1.90960983079259,2.57740144809259,528,696,4,3962.0M,4,3962.0M,0 +89,3871,3.9,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,160.4,1139.22,592.51,2.15722,1.74014315974444,2.49235606381852,520,692,3.9,3871.0M,3.9,3871.0M,0 +11,3928,4,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,158.511,1182,581.743,2.24768,2.03131325727037,2.57078796570115,495,705,4,3928.0M,4,3928.0M,0 +10,4037,4,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,158.422,1206.11,601.906,2.21874,1.86554255131111,2.5740864049,462,698,4,4037.0M,4,4037.0M,0 +83,3451,3.8,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,158.022,1206.56,612.103,2.10738,1.80968591098889,2.42291345926667,560,675,3.8,3451.0M,3.8,3451.0M,0 +33,3799,4,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,156.656,1186.56,638.769,2.22711,1.93705403287037,2.54165328781111,572,726,4,3799.0M,4,3799.0M,0 +32,3807,3.7,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,156.189,1220.22,589,2.06769,1.75518180766667,2.41343004633082,533,620,3.7,3807.0M,3.7,3807.0M,0 +92,3863,3.9,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,156.067,1172.89,619.78,2.19531,1.87710920426667,2.51980012746296,546,697,3.9,3863.0M,3.9,3863.0M,0 +21,3664,4,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,155.6,1171.22,623.569,2.2275,1.94174436563704,2.59279406646984,572,654,4,3664.0M,4,3664.0M,0 +16,2953,3.8,metronome,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,155.311,1214.67,601.858,2.12702,1.82024627324445,2.46117075950366,503,667,3.8,2953.0M,3.8,2953.0M,0 +57,3933,3.6,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,153.4,1237.44,589.732,2.0433,1.72971346642593,2.35461943930725,543,658,3.6,3933.0M,3.6,3933.0M,0 +54,3920,3.8,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,152.733,1205.44,640.774,2.10738,1.70697012734815,2.44314672038148,554,729,3.8,3920.0M,3.8,3920.0M,0 +35,3855,3.4,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,151.478,1208.11,543.617,1.90917,1.66040798704815,2.24154084253561,448,697,3.4,3855.0M,3.4,3855.0M,0 +42,4012,3.9,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,149.978,1268.56,597.696,2.17157,1.77261560618148,2.5110607102867,529,682,3.9,4012.0M,3.9,4012.0M,0 +4,1493,3.5,optthruput,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,1,149.333,1232.33,491.137,1.98318,1.71955089647407,2.30306681407044,484,513,3.5,1493.0M,3.5,1493.0M,0 +60,1833,3.7,metronome,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,149.178,1251.44,568.999,2.0722,1.80160129894815,2.41755914084926,558,624,3.7,1833.0M,3.7,1833.0M,0 +13,4057,4,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,148.233,1286.44,572.094,2.24373,1.89188739291111,2.60928065558889,522,717,4,4057.0M,4,4057.0M,0 +56,4092,3.8,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,147.567,1266.78,614.155,2.12662,1.80091134544815,2.49911958933401,535,704,3.8,4092.0M,3.8,4092.0M,0 +99,3277,3.7,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,147.311,1305.33,584.082,2.07174,1.83359568643333,2.45212266200124,493,655,3.7,3277.0M,3.7,3277.0M,0 +98,3595,3.8,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,147.1,1284.56,587.395,2.15139,1.82428965162593,2.47865789540743,483,704,3.8,3595.0M,3.8,3595.0M,0 +63,3998,3.9,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,147.067,1291.89,581.861,2.17379,1.87125756829259,2.52519199711485,488,653,3.9,3998.0M,3.9,3998.0M,0 +24,3691,4,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,146.7,1290.67,613.733,2.24321,1.97957693427778,2.56951391436296,516,767,4,3691.0M,4,3691.0M,0 +85,3762,3.9,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,146.233,1270.33,613.983,2.18256,1.8071707226963,2.51643383243145,550,682,3.9,3762.0M,3.9,3762.0M,0 +26,2796,3.7,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,146.167,1313.78,604.305,2.07285,1.74066725597407,2.38097096537841,508,722,3.7,2796.0M,3.7,2796.0M,0 +62,3756,4,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,146.133,1317.44,577.357,2.25465,1.93321083168148,2.60277501978519,517,650,4,3756.0M,4,3756.0M,0 +15,3551,3.7,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,146.122,1284.22,591.384,2.08757,1.77599265337037,2.37261477213703,540,641,3.7,3551.0M,3.7,3551.0M,0 +40,2602,3.7,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,145.156,1299.56,615.33,2.09652,1.88589083526296,2.41730957325936,486,729,3.7,2602.0M,3.7,2602.0M,0 +51,3656,3.7,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,144.811,1311.33,586.399,2.07528,1.79073693291111,2.38512245131481,498,674,3.7,3656.0M,3.7,3656.0M,0 +94,3799,3.7,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,144.711,1291.78,612.974,2.07605,1.77633201321852,2.43012740562726,562,689,3.7,3799.0M,3.7,3799.0M,0 +22,4045,3.8,metronome,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,144.689,1338.89,615.953,2.11811,1.8378266408037,2.44179334491481,529,697,3.8,4045.0M,3.8,4045.0M,0 +31,4043,3.9,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,144.3,1312.56,633.704,2.1703,1.84531696438519,2.51024464415185,568,702,3.9,4043.0M,3.9,4043.0M,0 +25,3311,3.4,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,144.056,1297.22,517.594,1.91899,1.66934573148148,2.24336049825003,475,581,3.4,3311.0M,3.4,3311.0M,0 +81,3993,3.8,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,144,1296.33,621.82,2.15787,1.87354810494815,2.45154982470792,555,729,3.8,3993.0M,3.8,3993.0M,0 +59,3732,4,balanced,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,1,143.222,1306.56,609.905,2.20706,1.94991007698148,2.53957654206296,543,728,4,3732.0M,4,3732.0M,0 +88,4091,4,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,142.522,1319.89,611.678,2.24159,1.86652237242222,2.58335691930741,541,676,4,4091.0M,4,4091.0M,0 +44,2694,3.8,optthruput,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,1,142.067,1348.44,591.965,2.13224,1.81551463864444,2.45494779215556,518,690,3.8,2694.0M,3.8,2694.0M,0 +52,3582,3.9,metronome,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,141.944,1334.67,618.581,2.20326,1.91894583545926,2.50999083591018,570,690,3.9,3582.0M,3.9,3582.0M,0 +17,3077,3.6,metronome,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,141.689,1384.67,591.106,2.02427,1.7158162843037,2.37516074295502,514,686,3.6,3077.0M,3.6,3077.0M,0 +78,3703,3.6,gencon,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,1,141.511,1367.78,578.246,2.01791,1.65973317238889,2.33003922404815,464,685,3.6,3703.0M,3.6,3703.0M,0 +87,3847,4,gencon,TRUE,TRUE,TRUE,1,140.5,1342.56,578.624,2.23752,1.90690225673704,2.5453491451,526,665,4,3847.0M,4,3847.0M,0 +80,1027,3.9,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,140.444,1378.22,383.283,2.17651,1.83474967061852,2.50642953648148,379,397,3.9,1027.0M,3.9,1027.0M,0 +96,3393,3.6,optthruput,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,1,140.433,1397.44,597.572,2.04179,1.71641337807778,2.35396112509368,516,695,3.6,3393.0M,3.6,3393.0M,0 +67,3138,3.9,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,138.456,1413.67,597.6,2.1786,1.8575628558,2.52243441837407,513,690,3.9,3138.0M,3.9,3138.0M,0 +23,2041,3.8,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,137.356,1407.78,544.816,2.14246,1.83072144487037,2.45001829676561,488,589,3.8,2041.0M,3.8,2041.0M,0 +93,3685,3.8,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,136.078,1390.44,586.475,2.14503,1.89153213484074,2.45895895723659,509,674,3.8,3685.0M,3.8,3685.0M,0 +74,2363,3.6,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,135.333,1437.56,575.237,2.03497,1.76225622496667,2.32406215306667,508,638,3.6,2363.0M,3.6,2363.0M,0 +46,3325,4,balanced,TRUE,TRUE,FALSE,1,135.211,1399.11,579.161,2.20738,1.83070499283704,2.54358642932963,487,656,4,3325.0M,4,3325.0M,0 +73,3556,3.9,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,134.422,1404.89,589.747,2.19486,1.85660076256667,2.50167221793704,513,705,3.9,3556.0M,3.9,3556.0M,0 +82,3603,3.7,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,133.2,1452.33,567.006,2.07182,1.77989898192963,2.44598176125874,507,632,3.7,3603.0M,3.7,3603.0M,0 +49,3473,3.9,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,132.544,1467.33,582.058,2.20202,1.90818192840741,2.5315053515,507,643,3.9,3473.0M,3.9,3473.0M,0 +72,3395,3.7,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,131.567,1452.89,583.663,2.06939,1.75482630201482,2.42650282065185,530,663,3.7,3395.0M,3.7,3395.0M,0 +48,2977,3.1,optavgpause,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,1,130.911,1460.67,550.872,1.76622,1.47325050811482,2.05711796548147,460,687,3.1,2977.0M,3.1,2977.0M,0 +50,3907,3.6,balanced,TRUE,TRUE,FALSE,1,130.233,1475.56,569.451,2.03947,1.66247094308148,2.40928777015267,537,636,3.6,3907.0M,3.6,3907.0M,0 +39,1089,3.3,optavgpause,TRUE,FALSE,FALSE,1,129.467,1516.89,385.332,1.87696,1.58987002311111,2.17285354254028,379,397,3.3,1089.0M,3.3,1089.0M,0 +20,2916,3.5,metronome,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,128.867,1488.56,589.091,2.00871,1.69908058649259,2.31697920444768,544,650,3.5,2916.0M,3.5,2916.0M,0 +38,3513,2.9,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,127.778,1510.22,499.981,1.66788,1.44292611474074,1.94757708285053,469,570,2.9,3513.0M,2.9,3513.0M,5.44444 +43,3249,3.6,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,127.656,1522.22,590.448,2.02304,1.74595086629037,2.36651354038724,505,679,3.6,3249.0M,3.6,3249.0M,6.11111 +58,3938,3.4,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,127.511,1508.22,478.456,1.94274,1.6496710438037,2.23321088230741,451,534,3.4,3938.0M,3.4,3938.0M,0 +70,3302,3.5,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,126.111,1552.11,593.177,1.99171,1.69334704917037,2.34154040561634,511,670,3.5,3302.0M,3.5,3302.0M,5.22222 +69,3548,3.8,optthruput,TRUE,TRUE,FALSE,1,125.656,1544.22,573.078,2.14529,1.83134995668148,2.45975470979167,500,637,3.8,3548.0M,3.8,3548.0M,0 +7,716,3.1,metronome,FALSE,FALSE,TRUE,1,123.622,1580.67,339.261,1.77697,1.54113873035556,2.09423695247062,334,354,3.1,716.0M,3.1,716.0M,0 +45,3840,3.3,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,122.556,1625.44,504.54,1.86214,1.58118264746667,2.16654990637418,440,589,3.3,3840.0M,3.3,3840.0M,0 +36,3443,3.5,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,122.522,1574.44,589.846,2.00691,1.76569070789259,2.29432244102222,535,633,3.5,3443.0M,3.5,3443.0M,0 +27,3205,3,metronome,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,122.378,1591.44,518.442,1.71397,1.43864951782593,2.01248994230588,423,677,3,3205.0M,3,3205.0M,7.44444 +37,3820,3.2,optavgpause,TRUE,FALSE,FALSE,1,121.2,1605.89,482.519,1.81232,1.58282440642593,2.08250560090338,416,537,3.2,3820.0M,3.2,3820.0M,7 +3,1760,2.7,optavgpause,TRUE,TRUE,FALSE,1,120.744,1589.56,526.141,1.56637,1.32288486215556,1.82920913800683,442,558,2.7,1760.0M,2.7,1760.0M,8.22222 +0,3021,2.9,optthruput,TRUE,TRUE,TRUE,1,120.422,1616,554.38,1.66581,1.43497164758148,1.9600595533394,414,700,2.9,3021.0M,2.9,3021.0M,0 +5,3357,3.2,optthruput,TRUE,FALSE,TRUE,1,117.311,1654.67,519.197,1.81517,1.4937307675,2.08376295616941,449,619,3.2,3357.0M,3.2,3357.0M,7.44444 +53,3384,3.4,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,116.922,1665.67,486.547,1.91591,1.64627941154074,2.23827129328519,451,534,3.4,3384.0M,3.4,3384.0M,6.55556 +29,2867,2.8,metronome,TRUE,TRUE,TRUE,1,114.767,1712.67,463.102,1.61132,1.37682914257778,1.87031562935185,427,537,2.8,2867.0M,2.8,2867.0M,10.5556 +90,3985,2.7,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,TRUE,1,114.289,1718.78,490.673,1.56716,1.35605404412593,1.84633931918095,459,525,2.7,3985.0M,2.7,3985.0M,0 +41,3640,3.5,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,111.344,1770.67,543.39,1.9898,1.69808306324815,2.30142973421738,500,612,3.5,3640.0M,3.5,3640.0M,6.44444 +47,2156,2.5,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,110.722,1772.22,522.351,1.46004,1.22142989221852,1.72431449546425,443,618,2.5,2156.0M,2.5,2156.0M,12 +8,360,3.3,gencon,TRUE,FALSE,TRUE,1,104.867,1876.33,278.53,1.90875,1.59308607184074,2.18433028078148,272,287,3.3,360.0M,3.3,360.0M,0 +1,587,2.6,balanced,FALSE,FALSE,FALSE,1,101.789,1929.11,327.423,1.50812,1.34814734756667,1.78405973617428,319,344,2.6,587.0M,2.6,587.0M,0 +30,3151,2.2,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,99.4222,2005.11,476.102,1.28995,1.12437086798519,1.50659213489243,415,602,2.2,3151.0M,2.2,3151.0M,10.4444 +2,2589,2.5,optavgpause,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,94.6333,2104.56,507.105,1.45725,1.20915729901111,1.71624341692299,439,576,2.5,2589.0M,2.5,2589.0M,7.88889 +91,3502,2,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,85.7,2345.78,454.401,1.18406,1.03295773092593,1.36994380666375,414,571,2,3502.0M,2,3502.0M,14.4444 +9,1529,1.9,optthruput,TRUE,FALSE,TRUE,1,85.1,2382,440.63,1.13714,0.980375231659259,1.30247372557037,398,479,1.9,1529.0M,1.9,1529.0M,25.5556 +19,2357,2.2,metronome,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,84.9,2375.67,448.269,1.29503,1.08860826107778,1.48737776725675,414,543,2.2,2357.0M,2.2,2357.0M,16 +68,3077,2.2,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,84.8333,2375.22,468.149,1.28998,1.12699390597778,1.49520631537839,421,579,2.2,3077.0M,2.2,3077.0M,19.2222 +18,3780,1.8,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,75.7222,2714.44,470.694,1.08602,0.964402175466667,1.24591116300741,408,601,1.8,3780.0M,1.8,3780.0M,21.7778 +75,3220,1.5,optthruput,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,73.4556,2778.33,442.861,0.958698,0.824575910092593,1.13868709375179,402,514,1.5,3220.0M,1.5,3220.0M,28 +28,3659,1.3,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,70.7333,2886.11,471.937,0.814116,0.718861871211111,0.949601361303704,412,570,1.3,3659.0M,1.3,3659.0M,23.8889 +6,2505,1.7,gencon,TRUE,FALSE,FALSE,1,70.5444,2915.56,436.514,1.03532,0.883571459940741,1.20059317127778,405,548,1.7,2505.0M,1.7,2505.0M,22.4444 +14,3471,1,balanced,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,1,50.9222,4117.67,415.401,0.665459,0.565577700374074,0.776884214905437,373,463,1,3471.0M,1,3471.0M,48.5556 +77,278,4,gencon,FALSE,TRUE,FALSE,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +