Inconsistency Between ThumbUpOffAltRounded and ThumbDownOffAltRounded Icons

[muradsofi]

Steps to reproduce

https://mui.com/material-ui/material-icons/?theme=Rounded&query=Thumb

Steps:

1. Open the Material UI icons library (Or link which is I provided).
2. Compare the ThumbUpOffAltRounded and ThumbDownOffAltRounded icons.
3. Notice the fill inconsistency where ThumbUpOffAltRounded is filled with black color and ThumbDownOffAltRounded is transparent.

Current behavior

The ThumbUpOffAltRounded icon is filled with black color, while the ThumbDownOffAltRounded icon is transparent inside, which leads to a visual inconsistency.

Expected behavior

Both ThumbUpOffAltRounded and ThumbDownOffAltRounded icons should have consistent fill styles (Both transparent)

Context

ThumbUpAltRounded and ThumbUpOffAltRounded icons appear to be the same in design, suggesting that the ThumbDownOffAltRounded might have been mistakenly created without a filled variant to match the ThumbUpOffAltRounded

Your environment

System: OS: macOS 14.1.1 Binaries: Node: 18.16.0 - ~/.nvm/versions/node/v18.16.0/bin/node npm: 9.5.1 - ~/.nvm/versions/node/v18.16.0/bin/npm pnpm: 8.4.0 - /opt/homebrew/bin/pnpm Browsers: Chrome: 120.0.6099.71 Edge: Not Found Safari: 17.1

Search keywords: ThumbUpOffAltRounded design inconsistency

[goswamianshuman]

Hey @muradsofi can you please add the screenshots for the problem, I think it will be more easier for everyone to get known with the issue.

[muradsofi]

@goswamianshuman Sure :)

As U can see from attached images, ThumbUpAltRounded and ThumbUpOffAltRounded are identical. However, technically, ThumbUpOffAltRounded should not have a filled color and should match the design of ThumbDownOffAltRounded.

[goswamianshuman]

@muradsofi I saw the issue, I want to ask that are you interested to work with this issue? If not then I will like to ask the maintainer to allow me for solving this issue.😊

[muradsofi]

@goswamianshuman Sorry saw the comment now, unfortunately I don't have enough "design" skills to fix this icon issue 😅
Feel free to contact maintaner. Thank U 🙌

[goswamianshuman]

@goswamianshuman Sorry saw the comment now, unfortunately I don't have enough "design" skills to fix this icon issue 😅
Feel free to contact maintaner. Thank U 🙌

Sure! then I'll open a PR here.😺

[michaldudak]

While it looks like a bug, it's consistent with Material Icons - see https://fonts.google.com/icons?icon.query=thumb+up+off+alt&icon.set=Material+Icons&icon.style=Rounded and https://fonts.google.com/icons?icon.query=thumb+down+off+alt&icon.set=Material+Icons&icon.style=Rounded

We don't accept fixes and any contributions that depart from what's in the Material Icons library. Please open an issue in Google's Material Icons repo to have this fixed.