diff --git a/kubernetes/main/apps/default/recyclarr/app/resources/recyclarr.yml b/kubernetes/main/apps/default/recyclarr/app/resources/recyclarr.yml
index c7a2874dbbe67..f032857b5d985 100644
--- a/kubernetes/main/apps/default/recyclarr/app/resources/recyclarr.yml
+++ b/kubernetes/main/apps/default/recyclarr/app/resources/recyclarr.yml
@@ -53,7 +53,7 @@ radarr:
     api_key: !env_var RADARR_API_KEY
 
     delete_old_custom_formats: true
-    replace_existing_custom_formats: true
+    replace_existing_custom_formats: false
 
     quality_profiles:
       - name: SQP-1 (1080p)