Switch item cannot be toggled in sitemap

[dilyanpalauzov]

For an item of type Switch in the sitemap I define

Switch item=r9 visibility=[r9_manual==ON] staticIcon="poweroutlet"
Text item=r9 visibility=[r9_manual==OFF] valuecolor=[ON="green", OFF="red"] staticIcon="poweroutlet"
Switch item=r9_manual mappings=[ON="Manual", OFF="Automatic"] labelcolor=[OFF="green", ON="red"] visibility=[!=NULL]

When I toggle over BasicUI the value of r9_manual, the interface is updated in both BasicOH and OH-Android (the first switch item is hidden, the text item is shown, or vice versa). So r9_manual is not NULL. But in Android-OH 3.17.4-beta neither the "Manual" nor the "Automatic" values is selected, the values are shown, but cannot be pressed. The labelcolor is correct.

[mueller-ma]

This might be caused by #3856. Can you post the Item definition of r9 and r9_manual?

[dilyanpalauzov]

The item definitions are:

Switch r9_manual "Control[]" <none> (gRele9) ["Switch"] {channel="mqtt:topic:r9:r9_manual"}
Switch r9        "9 Relay [MAP(switch.map):%s]" <poweroutlet> (gRele9) ["Switch"] {channel="mqtt:topic:r9:r9"}

Thing definitions (actually channel definitions within an MQTT thing):

Type switch  : r9        "Relay 9" [stateTopic="r9/status/switch:0", transformationPattern="JSONPATH:$.output", off="false", on="true", transformationPatternOut="MAP:abc.map", commandTopic="r9/rpc", postCommand="true" ]
Type switch  : r9_manual "Relay 9" [stateTopic="r9V/rpc", transformationPattern="JSONPATH:$.result.initial_state", off="off", on="restore_last"]

[mueller-ma]

And can you post the content of https://your server/rest/items/r9 and r9_manual?

[dilyanpalauzov]

{"link":"https://server/rest/items/r9","state":"ON", "transformedState":"Включено",
"stateDescription":{"pattern":"MAP(switch.map):%s","readOnly":false,"options":[]},
"metadata":{"semantics":{"value":"Point_Control_Switch","config":{"isPointOf":"gRele9"}}},
"editable":false,"type":"Switch","name":"r9",
"label":"9 Реле","category":"poweroutlet","tags":["Switch"],"groupNames":["gRele9"]}

{"link":"https://server/rest/items/r9_manual","state":"ON",
"stateDescription":{"pattern":"","readOnly":true,"options":[]},
"metadata":{"semantics":{"value":"Point_Control_Switch","config":{"isPointOf":"gRele9"}}},
"editable":false,"type":"Switch","name":"r9_manual",
"label":"Управление","category":"none","tags":["Switch"],"groupNames":["gRele9"]}

I use OpenHAB 4.2.2. The problem is only with the r9_manual Switch. The other sitemap-lines, bound to r9 are shown correctly - either the one, or the other.

Where does "readOnly":true come from?

[mueller-ma]

Where does "readOnly":true come from?

That question is better asked here: https://github.com/openhab/openhab-addons/ That might be a bug that needs to be resolved there.
Maybe the change in the client should be reverted until this issue is fixed.

[dilyanpalauzov]

I filled openhab/openhab-addons#18362. In the meantime I add dummy commandTopic="abc" in the MQTT-channel, then the item is read-write.