Deal with non-existing emails in migration

[michielbdejong]

No description provided.

[thhck]

Should we use a email that we ( the solidcommunity.net administrator ) control instead of a virtual one used by NSS2CSS ?

[michielbdejong]

Although the expected arguments suggests that xxx acts as a template variable in [email protected], looking at how this argument is used it seems we can only use it as a way to define the value for emailDomain.

> '[email protected]'.replace(/.*@+/, '');
'users.css.pod'
> 'xxxusers.css.pod'.replace(/.*@+/, '');
'xxxusers.css.pod'
> '[email protected]@s.pod'.replace(/.*@/, '');
's.pod'
> 'solidcommunity.net'.replace(/.*@/, '');
'solidcommunity.net'
> 'any@[email protected]'.replace(/.*@/, '');
'solidcommunity.net'
> 'blackhole.solidcommunity.net'.replace(/.*@/, '');
'blackhole.solidcommunity.net'

So I suggest we set the emailPattern argument to blackhole.solidcommunity.net so that it's clear that these emails will not have mailboxes behind them in general.

And then I think there is a step missing from the migration script which we should probably add ourselves: to extract the real email address from the root /.acl file of each NSS pod, and use that as the email address for the CSS pod. Only if that process fails we can fall back to assigning an @blackhole.solidcommunity.net email address.

Here you see for instance that the email address for michielbdejong.solidcommunity.net is [email protected]:

[bourgeoa]

And then I think there is a step missing from the migration script which we should probably add ourselves: to extract the real email address from the root /.acl file of each NSS pod, and use that as the email address for the CSS pod. Only if that process fails we can fall back to assigning an @blackhole.solidcommunity.net email address.

I see 2 issues with the proposal to use root/.acl email :

• some user may not remember the email they used on that userPod
• on NSS you could use the same email on many pods. This is forbidden in CSS and create an error.

CSS v7 allows for multiple accounts (email/password) for the same pod.
A solution could be found around creating a second account with the NSS user email/password when the email was not already used.

So I suggest we set the emailPattern argument to blackhole.solidcommunity.net so that it's clear that these emails will not have mailboxes behind them in general.

Well. Why not, but being a fake emailDomain make it short.

[michielbdejong]

See also bourgeoa/NSS2CSS#2