json-schema vocabulary: which version?

[ioggstream]

Question

• which specific json-schema version is used in the json-schema rdf vocabulary ?
• should it include $id together with id?

[egekorkan]

For your first question: TD is based on JSON Schema Draft7

[JKRhb]

@ioggstream Do you think this issue has been resolved in the meantime? Or is the the second question still open?

[ioggstream]

Hi!

• it would be great to explicitly have a reference pf JSON Schema Draft7 in the spec;
• can you point me to the answer to the second question in the spec?

Thanks again for all your support!
R.

[JKRhb]

Thank you for your swift response :)

Hi!

* it would be great to explicitly have a reference pf JSON Schema Draft7 in the spec;

I think this one should already be covered: https://www.w3.org/TR/wot-thing-description11/#bib-json-schema (For the mapping from Internet-Drafts to JSON Schema draft numbers see here: https://json-schema.org/specification-links#draft-7).

However, maybe the ontology should be updated as well, as it currently points to Draft 4, if I am not mistaken (see here: https://www.w3.org/2019/wot/json-schema#normative-references). Furthermore, I am not sure if citing JSON Schema as a normative reference in the ontology is correct as it is not a formal standard.

* can you point me to the answer to the second question in the spec?

I am not sure about this one – it seems to me as if the ontology currently says "no" to this question (see https://www.w3.org/2019/wot/json-schema#referencing-and-linking). Do you maybe have a better answer here, @egekorkan?

Thanks again for all your support! R.

[egekorkan]

@ioggstream regarding your second question: should it include $id together with id?

You are not required to use $id as schemas within a TD are not resolvable elsewhere. You can use it and nothing bad will happen.