Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
FIX(client): Fix AudioWizard echo cancellation checkbox
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
The echo cancellation checkbox had two separate, but similar
problems:

1) It would never load in a checked state when you open up the
AudioWizard

2) It would also never load the correct checked state representing
the user settings when switching AudioInput or AudioOutput systems.

The first problem can be traced back to commit 0104375
where the state of qcbEcho depends on the selected element of the AudioOutput
dropdown menu, before it has been filled.

The second problem probably goes back to 2991d20 where the
enabled state of the qcbEcho checkbox was changed on changing audio systems, but
the checked state was not reloaded.

This commit refactors the code (swaps initializing input and output)
and adds a shared method to update the qcbEcho checkbox appropriately.

Fixes mumble-voip#6544
  • Loading branch information
Hartmnt committed Oct 15, 2024
1 parent cb01bfa commit 2e67671
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Showing 2 changed files with 31 additions and 25 deletions.
54 changes: 29 additions & 25 deletions src/mumble/AudioWizard.cpp
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -44,26 +44,8 @@ AudioWizard::AudioWizard(QWidget *p) : QWizard(p) {
qcbUsage->setChecked(Global::get().s.bUsage);

// Device
if (AudioInputRegistrar::qmNew) {
foreach (AudioInputRegistrar *air, *AudioInputRegistrar::qmNew) {
qcbInput->addItem(air->name);
if (air->name == AudioInputRegistrar::current) {
qcbInput->setCurrentIndex(qcbInput->count() - 1);
EchoCancelOptionID echoCancelOptionId = firstUsableEchoCancellation(air, qcbOutput->currentText());
if (echoCancelOptionId != EchoCancelOptionID::DISABLED) {
qcbEcho->setEnabled(true);
qcbEcho->setChecked(Global::get().s.echoOption != EchoCancelOptionID::DISABLED);
}
}
QList< audioDevice > ql = air->getDeviceChoices();
}
}
if (qcbInput->count() < 2) {
qcbInput->setEnabled(false);
}

if (AudioOutputRegistrar::qmNew) {
foreach (AudioOutputRegistrar *aor, *AudioOutputRegistrar::qmNew) {
for (AudioOutputRegistrar *aor : *AudioOutputRegistrar::qmNew) {
qcbOutput->addItem(aor->name);
if (aor->name == AudioOutputRegistrar::current) {
qcbOutput->setCurrentIndex(qcbOutput->count() - 1);
Expand All @@ -73,11 +55,24 @@ AudioWizard::AudioWizard(QWidget *p) : QWizard(p) {
QList< audioDevice > ql = aor->getDeviceChoices();
}
}

if (qcbOutput->count() < 2) {
qcbOutput->setEnabled(false);
}

if (AudioInputRegistrar::qmNew) {
for (AudioInputRegistrar *air : *AudioInputRegistrar::qmNew) {
qcbInput->addItem(air->name);
if (air->name == AudioInputRegistrar::current) {
qcbInput->setCurrentIndex(qcbInput->count() - 1);
updateEchoCheckbox(air);
}
QList< audioDevice > ql = air->getDeviceChoices();
}
}
if (qcbInput->count() < 2) {
qcbInput->setEnabled(false);
}

qcbHighContrast->setChecked(Global::get().s.bHighContrast);
on_qcbHighContrast_clicked(Global::get().s.bHighContrast);
#ifdef Q_OS_WIN
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -243,8 +238,7 @@ void AudioWizard::on_qcbInputDevice_activated(int) {
air->setDeviceChoice(qcbInputDevice->itemData(idx), Global::get().s);
}

EchoCancelOptionID echoCancelOptionId = firstUsableEchoCancellation(air, qcbOutput->currentText());
qcbEcho->setEnabled(echoCancelOptionId != EchoCancelOptionID::DISABLED);
updateEchoCheckbox(air);

Global::get().ai = AudioInputPtr(air->create());
Global::get().ai->start(QThread::HighestPriority);
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -284,9 +278,7 @@ void AudioWizard::on_qcbOutputDevice_activated(int) {
bDelay = aor->usesOutputDelay();
}

AudioInputRegistrar *air = AudioInputRegistrar::qmNew->value(qcbInput->currentText());
EchoCancelOptionID echoCancelOptionId = firstUsableEchoCancellation(air, qcbOutput->currentText());
qcbEcho->setEnabled(echoCancelOptionId != EchoCancelOptionID::DISABLED);
updateEchoCheckbox(AudioInputRegistrar::qmNew->value(qcbInput->currentText()));

Global::get().ao = AudioOutputPtr(aor->create());
Global::get().ao->start(QThread::HighPriority);
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -767,6 +759,18 @@ void AudioWizard::on_qrbQualityCustom_clicked() {
restartAudio(true);
}

void AudioWizard::updateEchoCheckbox(AudioInputRegistrar *air) {
bool echoCancelPossible =
firstUsableEchoCancellation(air, qcbOutput->currentText()) != EchoCancelOptionID::DISABLED;

qcbEcho->setEnabled(echoCancelPossible);
if (echoCancelPossible) {
qcbEcho->setChecked(Global::get().s.echoOption != EchoCancelOptionID::DISABLED);
} else {
qcbEcho->setChecked(false);
}
}

EchoCancelOptionID AudioWizard::firstUsableEchoCancellation(AudioInputRegistrar *air, const QString outputSys) {
for (EchoCancelOptionID ecoid : air->echoOptions) {
if (air->canEcho(ecoid, outputSys)) {
Expand Down
2 changes: 2 additions & 0 deletions src/mumble/AudioWizard.h
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -20,6 +20,8 @@ class AudioWizard : public QWizard, public Ui::AudioWizard {
Q_OBJECT
Q_DISABLE_COPY(AudioWizard)

void updateEchoCheckbox(AudioInputRegistrar *air);

/// Which echo cancellation is usable depends on the audio backend and the device combination.
/// This function will iterate through the list of available echo cancellation in the audio backend and check with
/// the backend whether this echo cancellation option works for current device combination.
Expand Down

0 comments on commit 2e67671

Please sign in to comment.