Fix binary size computation for binary-size=2-4-8

NEWS

@@ -33,6 +33,18 @@ NEWS - user visible changes				-*- outline -*-
    patterns where invalid numerical data (e.g, SPACES) encode "absent"
    data
 
+** #1000: dialects without support of single byte binary data
+   will now generate at least 2 bytes of storage for COMP-5 elements; this
+   applies to all non-standard dialects but GnuCOBOL (default) and Micro Focus;
+   that changes the group length of records containing elements with less than
+   3 digits and also passes different sizes via CALL, which may need program
+   adjustments.
+
+** -std=acu / -std=acu-strict now generate BINARY and COMP-5 with at least
+   2 bytes of storage; the comment for #NNN above applies; if you want
+   to still use the sizes used since GnuCOBOL 2.2 with those dialects:
+   add -fbinary-size=1-2-4-8 to your compile options
+
 * Important Bugfixes
 
 ** #904: MOVE PACKED-DECIMAL unsigned to signed led to bad sign

cobc/ChangeLog

@@ -1,4 +1,12 @@
 
+2024-10-29  Simon Sobisch <[email protected]>
+
+	BUG #1000: Wrong binary size computed for COMP-5 PIC 9
+	and PIC 99 when binary-size=2-4-8
+	* field.c (validate_elementary_item): only set flag_real_binary for
+	  BINARY-CHAR/BINARY-SHORT/BINARY-LONG/BINARY-DOUBLE
+	* codegenc (output_attr): generate COB_FLAG_REAL_BINARY also for COMP-5
+
 2024-10-02  Simon Sobisch <[email protected]>
 
 	* pplex.l (output_line_directive): extracted from other places and

cobc/codegen.c

@@ -1630,27 +1630,28 @@ output_attr (const cb_tree x)
 				if (f->flag_binary_swap) {
 					flags |= COB_FLAG_BINARY_SWAP;
 				}
-				if (f->flag_real_binary) {
+				if (f->flag_real_binary
+				 || f->usage == CB_USAGE_COMP_5) {
 					flags |= COB_FLAG_REAL_BINARY;
 				}
 				if (f->flag_is_pointer) {
 					flags |= COB_FLAG_IS_POINTER;
 				}
-				if (cb_binary_truncate &&
-				    f->usage == CB_USAGE_BINARY &&
-				    !f->flag_real_binary) {
+				if (cb_binary_truncate
+				 && f->usage == CB_USAGE_BINARY
+				 && !f->flag_real_binary) {
 					flags |= COB_FLAG_BINARY_TRUNC;
 				}
 
-				if (type == COB_TYPE_NUMERIC_BINARY
-				 && f->usage == CB_USAGE_INDEX) {
-					flags |= COB_FLAG_REAL_BINARY;
-					type = COB_TYPE_NUMERIC_COMP5;
-				} else
-				if (type == COB_TYPE_NUMERIC_BINARY
-				 && (f->flag_binary_swap || f->flag_real_binary)
-				 && (f->flag_indexed_by || f->index_type || f->flag_internal_register)) {
-					type = COB_TYPE_NUMERIC_COMP5;
+				if (type == COB_TYPE_NUMERIC_BINARY) {
+					if (f->usage == CB_USAGE_INDEX) {
+						flags |= COB_FLAG_REAL_BINARY;
+						type = COB_TYPE_NUMERIC_COMP5;
+					} else
+					if ((f->flag_binary_swap || f->flag_real_binary)
+					 && (f->flag_indexed_by || f->index_type || f->flag_internal_register)) {
+						type = COB_TYPE_NUMERIC_COMP5;
+					}
 				}
 				switch (f->usage) {
 				case CB_USAGE_COMP_6:

cobc/field.c

@@ -2269,9 +2269,6 @@ validate_elementary_item (struct cb_field *f)
 		f->pic = cb_build_binary_picture ("BINARY-DOUBLE", 18, 0);
 		f->flag_real_binary = 1;
 		break;
-	case CB_USAGE_COMP_5:
-		f->flag_real_binary = 1;
-		break;
 	default:
 		break;
 	}
@@ -2516,8 +2513,6 @@ setup_parameters (struct cb_field *f)
 		break;
 
 	case CB_USAGE_COMP_5:
-		f->flag_real_binary = 1;
-		/* Fall-through */
 	case CB_USAGE_COMP_X:
 	case CB_USAGE_COMP_N:
 		if (f->pic->category == CB_CATEGORY_ALPHANUMERIC) {

config/ChangeLog

@@ -1,4 +1,8 @@
 
+2024-10-31  Simon Sobisch <[email protected]>
+
+	* acu-strict.conf: change binary-size from 1-2-4-8 to 2-4-8
+
 2024-08-17 Ammar Almoris <[email protected]>
 
 	FR #474: add runtime configuration to hide cursor for extended screenio

config/acu-strict.conf

@@ -88,7 +88,7 @@ indirect-redefines:		yes
 #               15 - 16   15 - 16      7
 #               17 - 18   17 - 18      8
 #
-binary-size:			1-2-4-8	# not verified yet
+binary-size:			2-4-8	# TODO: add 2-4-8-12-16
 
 # Numeric truncation according to ANSI
 binary-truncate:		yes