Look into AI Code suggestions

[SebieF]

          Suggestions from Codium AI for the version 0.9.0 PR.

PR Code Suggestions ✨

Category	Suggestion	Score
Security	Improve security by using yaml.safe_load() instead of yaml.load() Replace the use of yaml.load() with yaml.safe_load() to avoid potential security risks associated with loading arbitrary YAML content. biotrainer/inference/inferencer.py [86] -output_vars = yaml.load(tmp_output_file, Loader=yaml.RoundTripLoader) +output_vars = yaml.safe_load(tmp_output_file) Suggestion importance[1-10]: 10 Why: This suggestion addresses a significant security concern by replacing yaml.load() with yaml.safe_load(), which is a safer method for loading YAML content.	10
Possible bug	Correct the superclass initialization in the DeeperFNN class In the DeeperFNN class, the superclass initialization is incorrectly calling super(FNN, self).init() which should be super(DeeperFNN, self).init(). This ensures that the DeeperFNN class correctly initializes its superclass. biotrainer/models/fnn.py [38] -super(FNN, self).__init__() +super(DeeperFNN, self).__init__() Suggestion importance[1-10]: 10 Why: This suggestion addresses a critical bug in the superclass initialization of the DeeperFNN class, ensuring proper inheritance and functionality.	10
Performance	Optimize the removal of special tokens by using np.where() Use list comprehension directly in the np.delete() function to improve code readability and efficiency. biotrainer/embedders/huggingface_transformer_embedder.py [62-63] special_tokens_mask = self._tokenizer.get_special_tokens_mask(input_id, already_has_special_tokens=True) -embedding = np.delete(embeddings[seq_num], - [index for index, mask in enumerate(special_tokens_mask) if mask != 0], axis=0) +embedding = np.delete(embeddings[seq_num], np.where(special_tokens_mask)[0], axis=0) Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9 Why: Using np.where() improves both readability and performance. This change makes the code more efficient and easier to understand.	9
	Use torch.no_grad() to optimize inference performance Consider using torch.no_grad() context manager during inference to disable gradient computation, which can reduce memory consumption and increase computation speed. biotrainer/inference/inferencer.py [232] -inference_dict = solver.inference(dataloader, calculate_test_metrics=targets is not None) +with torch.no_grad(): + inference_dict = solver.inference(dataloader, calculate_test_metrics=targets is not None) Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9 Why: This suggestion correctly identifies a performance optimization by using torch.no_grad() during inference, which can reduce memory consumption and increase computation speed.	9
Robustness	Add exception handling for model state loading to manage file-related errors Implement exception handling for the torch.load function to manage potential errors during the loading of model states, such as file not found or corrupted files. biotrainer/solvers/solver.py [251] -state = torch.load(checkpoint_path, map_location=torch.device(self.device)) +try: + state = torch.load(checkpoint_path, map_location=torch.device(self.device)) +except FileNotFoundError: + logger.error("Checkpoint file not found.") + return +except Exception as e: + logger.error(f"Failed to load checkpoint: {str(e)}") + return Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9 Why: Adding exception handling for torch.load is a good practice to manage potential errors such as file not found or corrupted files. This enhances the robustness of the code.	9
Best practice	Improve type checking by using isinstance() Replace the direct type checks with isinstance() for better type checking, especially when dealing with inheritance. biotrainer/config/config_option.py [67-68] -return ("range" in str(self.value) or type(self.value) is list or - (type(self.value) is str and "[" in self.value and "]" in self.value)) +return ("range" in str(self.value) or isinstance(self.value, list) or + (isinstance(self.value, str) and "[" in self.value and "]" in self.value)) Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8 Why: Using isinstance() is a best practice for type checking, especially when dealing with inheritance. This change improves code robustness and readability.	8
	Use more specific exception types for clearer error handling Use a more specific exception type than the general Exception to provide clearer error handling. biotrainer/config/configurator.py [81-82] -except Exception as e: - raise Exception(f"Loading {embedder_name} automatically and as {tokenizer_class.__class__.__name__} failed!" - f" Please provide a custom_embedder script for your use-case.") from e +except ImportError as e: + raise ImportError(f"Loading {embedder_name} automatically and as {tokenizer_class.__class__.__name__} failed!" + f" Please provide a custom_embedder script for your use-case.") from e Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7 Why: Using a more specific exception type like ImportError provides clearer error handling and makes the code easier to debug. However, the improvement is minor and context-specific.	7
Enhancement	Enhance error messages for clarity and debugging Replace the manual exception raising for unknown split_name with a more informative error message that includes the available splits. biotrainer/inference/inferencer.py [191] -raise Exception(f"Unknown split_name {split_name} for given configuration!") +if split_name not in self.solvers_and_loaders_by_split: + available_splits = ', '.join(self.solvers_and_loaders_by_split.keys()) + raise ValueError(f"Unknown split_name '{split_name}'. Available splits are: {available_splits}") Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8 Why: The suggestion improves the clarity of error messages by including available split names, which aids in debugging and provides more informative feedback to the user.	8
	Apply dropout consistently to both feature and attention convolutions in the LightAttention class In the LightAttention class, the dropout operation is applied only to the output of feature_convolution but not to attention_convolution. Consistently applying dropout to both could potentially improve model performance by regularizing both features and attention mechanisms. biotrainer/models/light_attention.py [47] o = self.dropout(o) +attention = self.dropout(attention) Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8 Why: This suggestion potentially improves model performance by regularizing both features and attention mechanisms, making it a valuable enhancement.	8
	Enhance the _early_stop method by logging the reason for stopping Modify the _early_stop method to log the reason for stopping, which could be due to achieving a new minimum loss or reaching the patience limit. This enhances debugging and monitoring capabilities. biotrainer/solvers/solver.py [299] if self._stop_count == 0: + logger.info("Early stopping due to patience limit reached.") Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8 Why: Logging the reason for early stopping enhances debugging and monitoring capabilities, making it easier to understand why the training was stopped. This is a useful enhancement for tracking the training process.	8
	Improve variable naming for clarity in the FNN class's forward method In the FNN class, consider using a more descriptive variable name for the input tensor x in the forward method. Renaming x to input_tensor would improve code readability and make the method's purpose clearer. biotrainer/models/fnn.py [20] -def forward(self, x): +def forward(self, input_tensor): Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5 Why: While this suggestion enhances code readability, it is a minor improvement and does not address any functional issues.	5
Maintainability	Simplify dictionary creation from iterable using list comprehension Use list comprehension to simplify the creation of embeddings_dict from embeddings when it is not a dictionary. biotrainer/inference/inferencer.py [278] -embeddings_dict = {str(idx): embedding for idx, embedding in enumerate(embeddings)} +embeddings_dict = dict(enumerate(embeddings)) if not isinstance(embeddings, Dict) else embeddings Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7 Why: This suggestion simplifies the code for creating embeddings_dict from an iterable, improving code readability and maintainability. However, the improvement is minor.	7
	Refactor the mask calculation into a separate method in the LightAttention class The mask calculation in the forward method of the LightAttention class should be moved to a separate method to improve code readability and maintainability. This change will make the forward method cleaner and focus primarily on the forward pass logic. biotrainer/models/light_attention.py [43] -mask = x.sum(dim=-1) != utils.SEQUENCE_PAD_VALUE +mask = self.calculate_mask(x) +def calculate_mask(self, x): + return x.sum(dim=-1) != utils.SEQUENCE_PAD_VALUE + Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7 Why: This suggestion improves code readability and maintainability by separating concerns, but it does not address a critical issue.	7
	Refactor to separate training and validation into distinct methods for better modularity Refactor the train method to separate the training and validation phases into their own methods. This improves code readability and maintainability by modularizing the training process. biotrainer/solvers/solver.py [66] for epoch in range(self.start_epoch, self.number_of_epochs): + self._train_epoch(training_dataloader, epoch) + self._validate_epoch(validation_dataloader, epoch) Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7 Why: Refactoring the train method to separate training and validation phases improves code readability and maintainability. However, this suggestion requires additional implementation details for the new methods, which are not provided.	7
	Simplify dictionary initialization using comprehension Use dictionary comprehension to simplify the initialization of __DATASETS and __COLLATE_FUNCTIONS. biotrainer/datasets/init.py [9-22] -__DATASETS = { - Protocol.residue_to_class: ResidueEmbeddingsClassificationDataset, - Protocol.residues_to_class: ResidueEmbeddingsClassificationDataset, - Protocol.residues_to_value: ResidueEmbeddingsRegressionDataset, - Protocol.sequence_to_class: SequenceEmbeddingsClassificationDataset, - Protocol.sequence_to_value: SequenceEmbeddingsRegressionDataset, -} -__COLLATE_FUNCTIONS = { - Protocol.residue_to_class: pad_residue_embeddings, - Protocol.residues_to_class: pad_residues_embeddings, - Protocol.residues_to_value: pad_residues_embeddings, - Protocol.sequence_to_class: pad_sequence_embeddings, - Protocol.sequence_to_value: pad_sequence_embeddings, -} +__DATASETS = {protocol: dataset for protocol, dataset in zip( + [Protocol.residue_to_class, Protocol.residues_to_class, Protocol.residues_to_value, + Protocol.sequence_to_class, Protocol.sequence_to_value], + [ResidueEmbeddingsClassificationDataset, ResidueEmbeddingsClassificationDataset, ResidueEmbeddingsRegressionDataset, + SequenceEmbeddingsClassificationDataset, SequenceEmbeddingsRegressionDataset])} +__COLLATE_FUNCTIONS = {protocol: function for protocol, function in zip( + [Protocol.residue_to_class, Protocol.residues_to_class, Protocol.residues_to_value, + Protocol.sequence_to_class, Protocol.sequence_to_value], + [pad_residue_embeddings, pad_residues_embeddings, pad_residues_embeddings, + pad_sequence_embeddings, pad_sequence_embeddings])} Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6 Why: While dictionary comprehension can make the code more concise, it may also reduce readability for some developers. The improvement is more about code style and maintainability.	6

Originally posted by @CodiumAI-Agent in #92 (comment)