Tx execution and safe creation cannot be done with Ledger Nano S

[francovenica]

Bug description

Trying to create a tx shows an error when trying to sign
Trying to execute a tx shows an error regarding enabling blind signing, but the blind signing is enabled. Tried with adding an owner, sending funds, trying to execute a spending limit usage

There is NO issue signing tx, proposing tx or signing messages
None of this issues happen with a Ledger X

Environment

• Browser: Chrome
• Wallet: native ledger nano S
• Chain: Ethereum mainnet

Steps to reproduce

1. Try to create a safe with "Pay now" option using a ledger Nano S
2. Try to execute a tx in a safe with a ledger nano S

Expected result

Safe creation and execution should be possible like any other wallet

Screenshots

[schmanu]

I just tried Safe creation with my ledger imported through metamask without any issues.
So we can def. suggest that as a workaround.

@francovenica you put MetaMask into the environment of this ticket. But I guess you are not actually using Ledger through Metamask here? Could you put the correct environment to reproduce?

[schmanu]

@francovenica
Even when using Ledger directly without MetaMask I was able to create a Safe, sign and execute transactions.
Which version are you running in your Ledger including the version of your Ethereum Application.
I am running Ethereum version 1.10.2

[schmanu]

@francovenica
this is an issue with the new ledger firmware.
There are other users reporting similar errors for other txs: e.g. LedgerHQ/app-ethereum#311

I found this workaround that seems to fix it for some users: https://community.metamask.io/t/ledger-issue-please-enable-contract-data-but-its-already-enabled-and-enabling-debug-data-fixes-it/9679/3
Could you try that?
I think its not an issue with Safe{Wallet} though.

[francovenica]

@schmanu Sorry for taking so long to get back to this.

I tried with debug enabled and even with that still fails:
I get this error when trying to do a "Send funds".
I also get an error when I'm tryin got create a safe

[schmanu]

We have to wait for a new firmware version. I think this is a bug in the ledger firmware.

[francovenica]

Edited the description to point out this issue is with the native Ledger Nano S connection, not a MM import of that wallet.
I think that, if this is not a safe's issue, we should close this with a "won't fix".

[liliya-soroka]

Verified with the latest firmware version : execution and safe creation via Ledger Nano S direct connection work as expected